When Commercial Loan Risks Outweigh the Rewards

If you run your own business, a commercial loan can open doors, but it can also put your business and your home on the line. The aim is to know the risks before you borrow, so you choose a loan that suits your cash flow.

Many owners feel pressure to move quickly when a property or piece of equipment comes up. That is understandable. A little time spent on the risks now can save a lot of worry later.

What Are the Main Risks of a Commercial Loan?

The main risks are losing the asset you put up as security, struggling with repayments when income dips, and costs that are higher than you planned for. Each one can be managed, but only if you see it coming.

Unlike many home loans, a commercial loan is often assessed on your business income, the property itself and how the loan is structured. Lenders may look closely at your financials, so self employed borrowing can involve more paperwork and more questions than you expect.

How Does Security Put Your Assets at Risk?

With a secured commercial loan, you pledge an asset as collateral. If you cannot repay, the lender can sell that asset to recover the debt.

That asset might be the commercial property you are buying, or it might be your family home. The trade-off is that a business problem can become a household problem, because your home is at risk if the loan cannot be repaid.

An unsecured commercial loan does not need a specific asset pledged. However, lenders often still require a personal or director's guarantee. A guarantee can make you personally liable and expose personal assets, including your home, if the business cannot repay. Unsecured loans also often come with a higher interest rate and a smaller loan amount, depending on the lender. Read any guarantee carefully and get legal advice before you sign.

Can You Keep Up Repayments When Business Income Drops?

You can only keep up repayments if your loan is sized for your quietest months, not your best ones. Self-employed income can rise and fall, but loan repayments usually do not fall in slow months. Variable-rate repayments can also rise.

As an example, consider a Melbourne owner who runs a small trade business and wants to buy a warehouse. Her busy months cover the repayments easily, but two slow months each year leave her short. She and her broker test the repayments using the illustrative rate of 6.75% p.a. rather than a lower rate. On a loan of $800,000 over 25 years, principal and interest repayments at that rate come to about $5,527 a month. Seeing that figure, she lowers the loan amount by putting in a larger deposit and sets aside a cash buffer covering a few months of repayments. The outcome is a monthly repayment she can cover in slow periods, and a loan that does not rely on every month going well.

The rate in that example is illustrative only. Your actual rate will depend on your lender, deposit and the property. You can test your own numbers with the loan repayment calculator.

Variable or Fixed Interest Rate: Which Carries More Risk?

Neither is risk free. A variable interest rate can rise and lift your repayments, while a fixed interest rate gives certainty but can cost you if you want to leave or pay extra during the fixed period.

Fixed loans may come with break costs if you refinance or sell early, and some limit extra repayments. Variable loans can offer more flexible repayment options, but your repayments move with the market. Some owners split the loan so part is fixed and part is variable. That spreads the risk, though it also means you carry a bit of each downside.

Why Do Valuations and LVR Matter So Much?

A commercial property valuation sets how much a lender will let you borrow, because the loan is measured against that value as a commercial LVR (loan to value ratio). If the valuation comes in lower than the price you agreed to pay, you may need to find extra cash to close the gap.

Commercial lenders can also value a property cautiously, particularly for specialised buildings. It helps to ask your broker early how a lender is likely to view the property. You can also read about a property valuation report before you commit to a contract.

What Extra Risks Come With Construction or Development Loans?

Building or developing carries added risk because costs and timelines can change before the project earns any income. Delays, price rises and approval hold-ups can all stretch your budget.

With development finance, money is usually released in stages as work is completed, known as progressive drawdown. That protects you from paying interest on money you have not used yet. The trade-off is that you need enough cash to cover any shortfall if costs blow out. Lenders may also ask for a pre-sale or lease commitment before approving the loan, depending on the project.

Is Short-Term Bridging Finance Worth the Risk?

Bridging finance can be worth it when you have a clear way to repay it, but it is risky if that plan falls through. It is designed to cover a gap, such as buying before you sell.

For example, consider an owner who needs to buy a new industrial unit before selling the current one. A bridging loan lets them settle on time. If the sale takes longer than expected, the interest and fees keep building, and the cost is usually higher than a standard loan. The safest approach is to have a realistic sale timeline, a backup plan and a lender who explains the exit terms in writing.

How Can a Broker Help You Compare Commercial Loan Options?

A broker can compare lenders for you and match the loan structure to your income pattern, so you are not stuck with a poor fit. Different lenders treat self-employed income, security and fees differently.

Your accountant should also be part of the conversation, because loan structure can affect your tax position. Any tax outcome depends on your circumstances, so always get advice from your accountant. For more on what is available, see our commercial property loans page.

Borrowing for your business is a big step, and you do not have to work it out alone. Call one of our team or book an appointment at a time that works for you, and we will talk through the risks and options for your situation.

Frequently Asked Questions